
Hy4 flash vs GLM-5.3-Flash:より安いモデルは、ダウンロードできないほうだ
- GoogleNEWGoogle: Gemini 4 Carbon2026-11-10$2.00 / $10.00 100万トークンあたり · 90 tok/s
- AnthropicNEWAnthropic: Claude Fable 5.22026-11-09$8.00 / $40.00 100万トークンあたり · 97 tok/s
- orcaNEWOrca: OrcaC2 1.02026-11-0717 tok/s
- OrcaNEWOrcaCyber: GLM 5.3 Abliterated / Uncensored2026-11-04$3.00 / $5.00 100万トークンあたり · 87 tok/s
- OrcaNEWOrcaCyber: Hy4 Abliterated / Uncensored2026-11-04$0.80 / $1.60 100万トークンあたり · 133 tok/s
- OrcaNEWOrcaCyber: Kimi K3.1 Pro Abliterated / Uncensored2026-11-04$4.00 / $20.00 100万トークンあたり · 72 tok/s
- OrcaOrcaCyber: MiniMax M3.1 Flash Abliterated / Uncensored2026-10-29$0.80 / $1.60 100万トークンあたり · 130 tok/s
- OrcaOrcaCyber: GLM 5.3 Flash Abliterated / Uncensored2026-10-27$0.80 / $1.60 100万トークンあたり · 65 tok/s
- OrcaOrcaCyber: Qwen3.8 Flash Next Abliterated / Uncensored2026-10-26$0.80 / $1.60 100万トークンあたり · 92 tok/s
- OrcaOrcaCyber: MiMo V2.6 Flash Abliterated / Uncensored2026-10-26$0.80 / $1.60 100万トークンあたり · 43 tok/s
- MoonshotMoonshotAI: Kimi K3.1 Pro2026-10-2447知能
- OrcaOrcaCyber: DeepSeek V4.1 Flash Abliterated / Uncensored2026-10-23$0.80 / $1.60 100万トークンあたり · 193 tok/s
- minimaxMiniMax: M3.1 Flash2026-10-1929知能
- OrcaOrca: OrcaCyber Ultra 1.02026-10-17$5.00 / $10.00 100万トークンあたり · 150 tok/s
- deepseekDeepSeek: DeepSeek V4.1 Flash 10172026-10-1733知能
- DeepSeekDeepSeek: DeepSeek V4.1 Flash2026-10-1740知能
- OrcaOrca: OrcaCyber Zero 1.52026-10-10$3.00 / $7.50 100万トークンあたり · 119 tok/s
- openaiOpenAI: GPT-6.1 Sol2026-09-2955知能
- anthropicAnthropic: Claude Sonnet 5.52026-09-2855知能
- typesafeTypeSafe: Jev 1.132026-09-24$0.04 / $0.00 100万トークンあたり · 219 tok/s
Hy4 flash and GLM-5.3-Flash are aimed at the same buyer — someone who wants a million-token context window, image input and agent-grade tool calling without paying flagship rates — and they answer with almost identical price cards. Hy4 flash, released by Tencent on 16 November 2026, bills $0.070 per million input tokens and $0.281 per million output with $0.003 cached. GLM-5.3-Flash, which Zhipu launched and open-sourced on 26 August 2026, bills $0.15, $0.50 and $0.03 at list. Tencent is roughly half the price on input and a little over half on output, and ten times cheaper on cached input, which is the line that decides most agent budgets. It is also the model with no weights, no licence, no model card and no independent benchmark, against one that is MIT-licensed on Hugging Face and scores 27.8 on the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index.
それが一文で表した比較のすべてであり、きれいに決着するものではない。安価で検証不能なものと、高価で検査可能なものの対比は、マーケティング上の問題ではなく現実のトレードオフであり、どちらが勝つかはどちらのベンダーも明かさない事柄にかかっている。以下では、それぞれが実際に公表している内容、価格差が何をもたらし何を犠牲にするのか、そして判断が分かれるのはどこかを述べる。
2枚の価格カード、1行ずつ読み取る
まずは公表されている数字から始めましょう。この比較の中で、両社が明確に示しており、誰でも請求書と照合して確認できる唯一の数値だからです。
• 入力、100万トークンあたり — Hy4 flash $0.070、GLM-5.3-Flash $0.15。
• 出力、100万トークンあたり — Hy4 flash $0.281、GLM-5.3-Flash $0.50。
• キャッシュ済み入力、100万トークンあたり — Hy4 flash $0.003、GLM-5.3-Flash $0.03。
• コンテキストウィンドウ — Hy4 flash 1,048,576トークン、GLM-5.3-Flash 1,000,000トークン。
• トークンあたりのアクティブパラメータ — Hy4 flashは224B全体のうち12B(Engramパラメータ64Bを含む)、GLM-5.3-Flashは45層にわたる320B全体のうち18B。
• モデル重み — Hy4 flash は日程未定の計画として発表。GLM-5.3-Flash は公開初日から Hugging Face 上で MIT ライセンス。
• 独立系インテリジェンススコア — Hy4 flash は未公表。GLM-5.3-Flash は Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index で 27.8、同じラボの Coding Index では 71.5。
The cached-input line deserves more attention than it usually gets. At $0.003 per million, Hy4 flash caches cheaper than GLM-5.3-Flash by a factor of ten, and cheaper than its own flagship Tencent HY4 by a factor of a hundred. For an agent that re-sends a fixed system prompt, a tool schema and a retrieved document on every step, the cache rate is the rate you actually pay most of the time, and a tenfold difference there outweighs the twofold difference on fresh input. If your workload is retrieval-heavy, Hy4 flash's advantage is larger than the headline price suggests. If your workload is one-shot generation with no reuse, the advantage narrows to the input and output ratios.
Both price cards are promotional in part. Tencent Cloud's TokenHub is running 50% off for an unstated limited period and WorkBuddy is free until 30 November. Zhipu's 50%-off launch rate expired on 9 September 2026 and was not extended, which is why the $0.075 and $0.25 figures that circulated in late August no longer apply — the rate above is the standing one. Assume Tencent's promotion ends the same way and budget the list rate.
パラメータの差は価格の差よりも小さい。

Hy4 flash activates 12 billion parameters per token against GLM-5.3-Flash's 18 billion, a third less compute per token, and that is the mechanical reason it can be sold at half the price. The interesting part is the total: 224 billion against 320 billion, with 64 billion of Tencent's total sitting in Engram parameters that hold learned associations rather than running in every forward pass the way a routed expert does. Tencent has not published a layer count, expert count or routing width for Hy4 flash, so the closest thing to an architectural comparison is that both are sparse mixture-of-experts models with a small active fraction and both vendors chose that design for the same reason — serving cost scales with active parameters, not total ones.
GLM-5.3-Flash's design is documented in more detail, and that documentation is checkable because the weights are public: 45 layers, hybrid sparse-plus-linear attention, an approach to residual connections Zhipu calls Manifold-Constrained Hyper-Connections, and an IndexPool mechanism that compresses four indexer key vectors into one weighted pool to cut long-context latency. Pre-training ran on a 30-trillion-token multimodal corpus. None of that is independently audited, but it is at least a description specific enough to be falsified by anyone who downloads the checkpoint.
The asymmetry is not that Zhipu published and Tencent did not. Both published; they published different kinds of thing. Zhipu described a model, which is a claim about structure that a checkpoint can confirm or refute. Tencent described a result — a KV cache a sixth the size of its flagship's, output length halved by self-distillation, better than 150 tokens per second of decode from four-bit quantization and a megakernel — which is a claim about behaviour that only reproduction can settle. Results are the more commercially interesting claims and the harder ones to check. On a model with public weights, a serving claim gets tested by strangers within weeks; on a model without them, it stays a sentence on a research page for as long as the vendor wants.
このうち1つはダウンロードできます
これはかなりの割合の購入者にとって決定的な違いであり、しかもその差は僅差ではない。GLM-5.3-FlashはMITライセンスの下、FP8およびBF16で、Hugging Faceのzai-org/GLM-5.3-Flashに公開されており、2026年8月26日からその状態が続いている。MITライセンスは、収益のしきい値を設けることなく、商用利用、改変、ファインチューニング、再配布を認めている。このモデルは3か月近く広く一般に使用されてきた。つまり、推論スタック側もこれに対応済みである。量子化版も存在し、サービングのレシピも存在し、その挙動に関するあらゆる主張は実行して検証できる。
Nothing like it exists for Hy4 flash. The commitment there is a sentence about future plans, hedged with an intention to keep iterating, and it names no licence and no date. Tencent has done this properly before — the August preview landed under Apache 2.0 with weights on four hosting sites and vLLM and SGLang recipes on day one — so the pattern is not in doubt. What is in doubt is the timidity of the current language, which reads like a commitment to a process rather than to an artefact. Anyone planning to fine-tune, self-host, or build a cost model around running their own inference should treat Hy4 flash as API-only until a repository appears.
The same asymmetry applies to evidence. GLM-5.3-Flash has two numbers from a harness neither vendor wrote: 27.8 on the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index and 71.5 on its Coding Index. Both are checkable, and the pair says something specific: a 71.5 on coding against 27.8 on the general index describes a model that is genuinely good at one thing and ordinary at everything else, which is exactly what a cheap tier should be. That is the kind of distinction a single headline score erases, and it is why the remaining vendor figures in this piece are presented as claims rather than results. Hy4 flash has no independent score, and its benchmark results — DeepSWE, Terminal-Bench 4.0, APEX-Agents, OSWorld 2.1 and Tencent's internal suites — exist only as chart images on the vendor's research page. That is not a reason to distrust them. It is a reason to treat them as hypotheses.
各ベンダーが測定した内容と、打ち負かした相手
両社は比較を公表したが、それぞれ別の対象と自社を比較していた。これは各社が自らの弱点を何だと考えていたかを物語っている。
Tencent's headline is a blind test: 85 WorkBuddy users, 27 task categories, 259 real daily-work tasks, with Hy4 flash reported as landing close to Claude Haiku 5.5 on satisfaction while carrying the lowest per-task cost and shortest task duration in the panel. Note "close to," not "better than," and note the panel is the vendor's own employees in the vendor's own product. The supporting claim is per-task cost on WorkIndex, Tencent's internal eight-suite benchmark: one-thirteenth of Hy4 preview, one-twentieth of Tencent HY4, one-eighth of DeepSeek-V4.1-Flash-1017. Against GLM-5.3-Flash the only published figure is a 2.52% gain in general chat inside 元宝, which is a product metric on one consumer app and does not transfer to anything you would run.
Zhipu's positioning is different: it sells the model as frontier-adjacent capability at flash cost, prices it against its own 743B flagship, and points to open weights and an exploit-evaluation result as proof the cheap model is not a toy. Its internal figures have already taken one independent correction, and the AA number is the one to quote.
実際的な帰結として、どちらのベンダーも中立なハーネス上での直接比較を公開しておらず、本来欲しい比較——同じタスク、同じプロンプト、同じハーネス、両方のモデル——は存在しない。自分で実行するしかない。すでに実施している10個のタスクでトークン数を記録すれば、自分のトラフィックに対して結論を出すには十分であり、どちらのローンチページよりも価値がある。
マルチモーダリティをめぐる2つの異なる賭け
GLM-5.3-Flashはテキスト、画像、動画をネイティブに入力として受け付けます。視覚を別個のアダプター経由でルーティングするのではなく、これをネイティブに行った最初のGLM-5モデルです。これは文書化された検証可能な主張であり、重みは公開されているため、許可を求めることなく確認できます。
Hy4 flash is described as multimodal, and the WorkIndex suite it was measured on includes visual understanding as one of eight task types. Tencent has not said whether the vision path is native or an adapter, has not published the encoder's size, and has not said whether video is supported at all. The most that can be said is that image input is part of the pitch and that the model's predecessor in the family — Tencent HY4, general availability 4 November 2026 — added native vision and computer use as its headline feature, so the capability is plausible for a model distilled from it. Plausible is not documented.
スクリーンショット、チャート、スキャンした文書、動画フレームがパイプラインで重要な役割を果たすなら、GLM-5.3-Flash は採用を決める前にマルチモーダルな挙動を検証できるモデルです。画像の利用が時々であれば、その差は価格ほど重要ではありません。
決定が分かれるところ
Choose Hy4 flash when the volume is the problem and the task is office-shaped. Document processing, retrieval over a long corpus, slide generation, simple frontend work, computer-use loops — these are the workloads Tencent built it for, the ones its internal product data covers, and the ones where a tenfold cache discount and a 50% output-length cut compound into something an order of magnitude cheaper. Run it on your own tasks first and watch output tokens: if the model really is terser, your bill falls further than the rate card predicts, and if it is terser because it is shallower, you will see that in the same measurement.
Choose GLM-5.3-Flash when you need the artefact, the audit, or the modality. Fine-tuning, on-premises serving, regulated data, a licence you can show a lawyer, video input, or a score from a harness nobody at Zhipu wrote — all of these point one way. At $0.15 and $0.50 it is not expensive; it is roughly a tenth of GLM-5.3's list price for a model that has already survived independent measurement.
ワークロードが混在しているなら、両方を選べ。 この2つのリリースを正直に読み解くと、実際には代替品ではない。一方は大量の日常業務向けのコスト最適化されたAPIモデルであり、もう一方はベンダーの管理下から外れる必要があるあらゆるもの向けに、アーキテクチャが文書化されたオープンチェックポイントだ。両方に到達できるルーターは、片方を選んで間違えるよりも安価な答えだ。

今日、実際に呼び出せるものは何ですか?
This is where the two models differ operationally as well as commercially. GLM-5.3-Flash is in the OrcaRouter catalogue as z-ai/glm-5.3-flash at the provider's list price of $0.15 per million input and $0.50 per million output, with a rate-limited free tier alongside it for evaluation. Hy4 flash is not routed here — Tencent has not made it available to us — so anyone comparing the two needs Tencent's own TokenHub for the flash side and can use the same OrcaRouter key for the GLM side.
That split is worth using rather than resenting. OrcaRouter passes provider list price through with no markup, which means the GLM side of your comparison is billed at exactly Zhipu's rate and stays correct if Zhipu moves it; there is no reseller table to go stale. And for the evaluation itself, having tencent/hy4-preview on the same key as z-ai/glm-5.3-flash is useful even though it is not the model in question: the preview is the model Hy4 flash was distilled from, so it is the natural control when you test whether the small model's answers hold up. One key, more than 200 models, and a failover path if a launch-week endpoint turns out to be unreliable — which, for a model released six days ago with no public uptime record, is a reasonable thing to want.

価格は問題ではない
Tencent has built the cheaper model, and on the numbers it is cheaper by a margin that matters: half on input, a little over half on output, a tenth on cache. What it has not built is a model you can inspect. No weights, no licence, no architecture detail, no independent score, benchmarks behind pixels, and a headline comparison drawn from a panel of its own staff. Zhipu built the more expensive one and published enough that its weaknesses — including a vendor index that independent measurement cut by fifteen points — are on the record where you can weigh them.
ローンチから6日後、選択の構図はこうだ。仕様が文書化されていないモデルに対する実証済みの割引を取るのか、それとも、まだ非常に低い価格で仕様が文書化されたモデルを選ぶのか。割引はおそらく本物で、文書化の不足はおそらく一時的なものだ。どちらも確実ではない。見極める方法は、四半期をかけて選ぶことではなく、午後をかけて測定することだ。
この記事で比較したモデル3
この記事から検出 · ベンチマーク:Artificial Analysis · 毎日更新
