A generated 16:9 title card on a deep blue-grey background with a soft radial glow, headlined 'Qwen4-Max vs Kimi K3.1 Pro' and subtitled 'A 41-cent gap that decides less than you think'. To the right, a flat balance scale drawn in thin lines holds two pans labelled $3.27 per task and $3.68 per task with the beam almost level. A row of four small icons along the bottom is labelled video in, 1M context, no weights versus open weights, and 55 vs 31 tok/s. OrcaRouter logo bottom-right.
Guides & Insights

Qwen4-Max vs Kimi K3.1 Pro: A 41-Cent Gap That Decides Less Than You Think

Author

jinhao.song

Date Published

Latest models · 20View all models →
Benchmarks: Artificial Analysis · updated daily
Back to all posts

On Artificial Analysis's own numbers, a finished task costs $3.27 on Qwen4-Max and $3.68 on Kimi K3.1 Pro. Forty-one cents. If you are choosing a model for an agent that runs thousands of tasks a week, that gap looks like the whole decision, and it is not — because the two models reach those figures from opposite directions, and the direction is what shows up in your logs six weeks later. Qwen4-Max gets there by being fast and verbose — more output tokens, at less than half the rate per token; Kimi K3.1 Pro gets there by being slow and terse, emitting fewer tokens that each cost more than twice as much. Neither is the cheaper model in general. Each is cheaper for a particular shape of work.

That is the useful framing for this pair, and it is available now in a way it was not in October: both models are on the same independent index revision, both have published commercial terms, and one of them has downloadable weights. What follows is the split by workload rather than by benchmark, because the benchmark already says they are close.

First, the name

There is no plain kimi-k3.1 in M​oonshot's own model list. The shipped identifiers are kimi-k3.1-pro, kimi-k3.1-pro-highspeed and the older kimi-k3; "Kimi K3.1" is how the series gets written in search boxes and in the press, and the model behind it is Kimi K3.1 Pro. The highspeed variant is the same model served at roughly two to three times the speed. So every comparison that matters here is Qwen4-Max against Kimi K3.1 Pro, and that is the pair measured below. Anyone showing you a spec sheet for a model called exactly "Kimi K3.1" is showing you the Pro's numbers under a shorter name.

Kimi K3.1 Pro was announced on 23 October 2026 with the vendor's blog dated the 24th, and its weights landed on Hugging Face with a single commit timestamped 2026-11-02. Qwen4-Max went on metered sale on 16 November 2026. Both are weeks old, neither is a preview, and both have real rate cards — which is the whole reason this comparison can be made with numbers instead of projections.

A generated two-column scoreboard titled 'Qwen4-Max vs Kimi K3.1 Pro' with seven rows: index score 43 against 46; cost per task $3.27 against $3.68; output per million $4.50 against $10.00; tokens per run 127M against 113M; wall-clock per task 32.1 min against 38.4 min; max output 262,144 against 943,000; weights none against downloadable. Footer reads 'Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5.0.1; vendor list prices'. OrcaRouter logo bottom-right.

The two rows that define the matchup

Everything below is from Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5.0.1 unless marked as vendor-reported. The index is one instrument on one day; this blog has seen revisions move a model's score by double digits, so treat the spread as directional.

• Index score — Qwen4-Max 43 versus Kimi K3.1 Pro 46. The K​imi model is ahead by three points, inside the noise band of a single index revision

• Cost per task — Qwen4-Max $3.27 versus Kimi K3.1 Pro $3.68. The K​imi model is 12.5% more expensive per finished task despite the score advantage

• Input price — Qwen4-Max $1.50 per million in Singapore, $1.413 elsewhere; Kimi K3.1 Pro $2.00

• Output price — Qwen4-Max $4.50 versus Kimi K3.1 Pro $10.00. This is the widest gap in the whole comparison, and it is the one a cost model built on token counts will over-weight

• Cache-hit price — Qwen4-Max $0.075 per million in Singapore, $0.071 elsewhere; Kimi K3.1 Pro $0.20. Both discount cached reads heavily; Q​wen's is the steeper discount

• Wall-clock per task — Qwen4-Max 32.1 minutes versus Kimi K3.1 Pro 38.4 minutes, against a field median of 11.5. Both are slow; Q​wen is the less slow of the two

• Throughput — Qwen4-Max 55 output tokens per second versus Kimi K3.1 Pro 31, measured on each vendor's own API

• Token appetite — Qwen4-Max 127 million output tokens per index run versus Kimi K3.1 Pro 113 million

• Context — Qwen4-Max 1,000,000 tokens as documented, measured at 984,000 usable; Kimi K3.1 Pro 1,048,576

• Modality — both take text, image and video and return text. M​oonshot's model guide is explicit that Kimi K3.1 Pro handles video, even though the independent summary of the model lists only text and image

• Weights — Qwen4-Max publishes none, and its documentation marks fine-tuning and deployment unsupported; Kimi K3.1 Pro's 2.8-trillion-parameter checkpoint, 104 billion of them active per token, is downloadable under a bespoke licence rather than an off-the-shelf one

• Architecture, vendor-reported — Qwen4-Max a 2.4-trillion-parameter backbone with 71 billion active and a further 328 billion N-gram embedding parameters; Kimi K3.1 Pro a post-trained 3T-class model built on K3

Read the output-price row against the cost-per-task row and you have the whole article. Kimi K3.1 Pro charges more than twice as much per output token and still finishes a task for 41 cents more, because it emits fewer of them. Qwen4-Max charges less than half as much per output token and gains almost nothing from it, because it emits 12% more. Per-token pricing is a proxy for the bill, not the bill. The bill is the third row.

Workload one: the long-running agent

This is where the 41 cents stops being rounding. An agent loop does not run one task; it runs a retry-heavy sequence of them, and the number that compounds is wall-clock, not price. At 32.1 and 38.4 minutes per index task respectively, both models are between two and three times slower than the field median of 11.5 minutes. A twenty-task batch is ten to thirteen hours of wall-clock on either. If your loop is latency-bound, neither of these is the right model, and picking between them on price is optimising the wrong variable.

If it is not latency-bound — batch overnight runs, long-horizon research jobs, background document work — then the deciding number is tokens per completed task, and here Qwen4-Max's 55 tokens per second against K​imi's 31 matters less than it looks. Throughput only sets how fast a single request drains; what sets the bill is how many tokens the model spends thinking before it produces an answer. Qwen4-Max spends 12% more of them and charges 55% less per unit for them.

Workload two: everything that touches a long document

This is where the comparison stops being about scores and becomes about the shape of the output. Both models read text, images and video and both write text, so there is no modality argument to make — the honest version of this section is that Qwen4-Max's video support is not the tiebreaker it looks like, because M​oonshot's model guide says Kimi K3.1 Pro handles video too. What separates them on document work is how much they will write back in one pass, and what they charge for it.

Qwen4-Max caps output at 131,072 tokens with thinking off, or 262,144 shared between thinking and answer. Kimi K3.1 Pro goes to roughly 943,000. For a contract review that returns a summary, that difference never appears; for a pipeline asked to re-emit a whole marked-up document, or to reason across a working set and then write the result out at length, it is the difference between one call and a chunking scheme you now have to build and debug.

The price gap points the other way. Qwen4-Max's input rate is 25% lower and its output rate less than half, so extraction-and-classify work over a large corpus — lots in, little out — is meaningfully cheaper on Qwen4-Max per finished task as well as on the meter. Read the two paragraphs together and the split is clean: short answers over a big corpus favour Qwen4-Max, long answers over the same corpus favour the K​imi model's output ceiling.

A screenshot of the Artificial Analysis page for Kimi K3.1 Pro, marked open weights and released October 2026, showing the Intelligence Index score of 46 against a median of 23, 113M tokens generated on the run, $2.00 input and $10.00 output per million tokens, $3.68 per task, 38.4 minutes per task against a median of 13.6, text and image input, a 1M-token context and downloadable weights on Hugging Face.

Workload three: the one where you need the weights

Nothing in the rows above covers the largest difference between these two models, because it is not a number. Kimi K3.1 Pro can be downloaded. Qwen4-Max cannot — its documentation marks fine-tuning and model deployment as unsupported, and A​libaba's launch post promises only that smaller Qwen4 tiers are "coming to open source", which is a statement about the family rather than about this model.

That matters in three specific situations and is irrelevant in the rest. It matters if you need to fine-tune on your own data, because Qwen4-Max offers no path to it at all. It matters if your compliance posture requires the weights to sit inside your own perimeter rather than behind somebody's API. And it matters if you are modelling cost over years rather than months: a downloadable 3T-class checkpoint is a capital expense with a marginal cost curve you control, while a rented flagship is a rate card that can move. A 3-trillion-parameter mixture-of-experts is not something most teams can serve in-house — it wants a rack, not a workstation — but "expensive to run yourself" and "impossible to run yourself" are different answers to a procurement question, and only one of them closes.

The licence deserves one sentence of precision, because "open weights" is doing a lot of work in most coverage: Kimi K3.1 Pro ships under a bespoke Kimi K3.1-Pro License, not the Modified MIT text that K3 carried, and its grant is permissive in the ordinary sense — use, modify, fine-tune, redistribute, sell — with two conditions bolted on. If you operate a model-as-a-service business and your aggregate revenue passes $20 million over any twelve consecutive months, you need a separate agreement with M​oonshot before using the weights commercially. And if a product built on them passes 100 million monthly active users or $20 million in monthly revenue, "Kimi K3.1-Pro" has to be displayed prominently in its interface. Internal use, and use through M​oonshot's own products or certified inference partners, sit outside both clauses. If you plan to build a product on top of the weights, read the licence rather than the summary.

Putting the pair on one key

Here the comparison stops being symmetrical in a way that is worth being blunt about. OrcaRouter routes kimi/kimi-k3.1-pro today, on the same OpenAI-compatible endpoint as the rest of its 200-plus model identifiers, at 0% markup — the provider's list price passed through, so the $2.00 and $10.00 above are what you pay rather than what the vendor charges before somebody's margin. It does not route Qwen4-Max, and this page will not suggest otherwise: reaching that model means A​libaba's own six regions or a third-party platform reselling it.

What that asymmetry is actually good for is the test this article has been describing. The per-workload split above is a hypothesis about your traffic, not a fact about your traffic, and the cheap way to falsify it is to run the same prompts through Kimi K3.1 Pro and a Q​wen 3.8 tier on one endpoint, with automatic failover covering the provider hiccups that otherwise corrupt a benchmark run. If the K​imi model wins on your workload by more than 41 cents a task, the weights argument gets easier to justify. If it does not, you have saved yourself a procurement conversation about a rack.

A screenshot of the OrcaRouter model page for Kimi K3.1 Pro, showing the identifier kimi/kimi-k3.1-pro, the byline MoonshotAI with the date 2026-10-24, a description noting a 1,048,576-token context and up to 943,718 output tokens with text, image and video input, a 1M-token context badge, 943k maximum output, pricing of $2.00 input and $10.00 output per million, and a note that zero data retention is available.

The decision rule

Three points of index and 41 cents of cost per task do not separate these models. The things that do are binary, and they are worth checking in this order.

• If you need to write a whole document back in one call — Kimi K3.1 Pro's ~943,000-token output ceiling against Qwen4-Max's 262,144 shared budget is a categorical difference, not a percentage one

• If you need to fine-tune, self-host, or hold the weights — Qwen4-Max is out, because there are no weights to hold

• If your runs are wall-clock bound — neither is a good fit; both are two to three times slower than the median model on the same board, and K​imi is the slower of the two

• If none of those apply — take the cheaper per finished task, which on today's numbers is Qwen4-Max at $3.27 against $3.68, and re-check it in a month, because both vendors have moved their prices once already this quarter

The honest summary is that M​oonshot shipped the better-scoring model and A​libaba shipped the better-priced one, that the gap in each direction is small, and that the only choice here with a long tail is the one nobody puts in a comparison table: whether you are renting or owning. Everything else is forty-one cents and a rounding error on a revision.

Compared in this article1

Detected from this article · Benchmarks: Artificial Analysis · updated daily