A generated title card reading 'Qwen4-Max was called an Opus 5.5 beater' with the subtitle 'The index puts it 16 points back' and three figure cards reading '43 vs 59 on the index', '$3.27 vs $1.27 per task' and 'time per task: not published'. A footer reads 'Index, per-task cost and time per task per Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5.0.1, read 16 November 2026.' Flat vector styling on a white background with blue-and-cyan gradient accents, the OrcaRouter mark composited bottom right.
Guides & Insights

Qwen4-Max Was Called an Opus 5.5 Beater: The Index Puts It 16 Points Back

Author

jinhao.song

Date Published

Latest models · 20View all models →
Benchmarks: Artificial Analysis · updated daily
Back to all posts

The launch-day verdict on Qwen4-Max was that it beats Claude Opus 5.5 and both GPT-6.1 Sol and GPT-6 Astra, and trails only Claude Fable 5.2. Three of those four comparisons run the other way on the one scoreboard that ran all five models through the same nine evaluations. Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5.0.1, read on 16 November 2026 — the day Qwen4-Max went on sale — puts Qwen4-Max at 43, Claude Opus 5.5 at 59, GPT-6 Astra at 57, GPT-6.1 Sol at 55 and Claude Fable 5.2 at 65. Sixteen points behind the model it was said to beat, fourteen behind the second-cheapest of the three, and twelve behind the third. The fourth comparison, the one where Fable 5.2 is out in front, is the only part of the claim that survives contact with the harness.

That gap is worth taking apart rather than dismissing, because the claim is not invented. It is what you get when a comparison is assembled from reasoning-effort settings that do not match, and the mismatch happens to run in one direction every time. Below: what A​libaba actually published, what the scoreboard reads at each rung of each ladder, the one reading under which the claim becomes literally true, and the figure the tracker does not have for Qwen4-Max at all.

What A​libaba published, and what it did not

The first thing to separate is the vendor's launch material from the commentary around it. A​libaba's own Qwen4-Max blog post, dated 16 November 2026, mentions no competing model by name anywhere in its 3,100 words. Every comparison in it is against Qwen3.8-Max, the company's own previous flagship. That is a normal thing for a launch post to do and it is not a criticism — but it means the competitive framing did not come from the vendor, and any "beats Opus" statement in circulation is an inference somebody else drew.

What the vendor does claim, all of it vendor-reported and unreproduced:

• Architecture — a 2.4-trillion-parameter backbone on a new Qwen4 architecture, with native vision and a one-million-token context window.

• Token efficiency against Qwen3.8-Max — 24% fewer tokens at Xhigh effort and 35% fewer at High on A​libaba's Work360 benchmark, and 48% and 49% fewer on Terminal-Bench 4.0.

• Cost per task against Qwen3.8-Max — an average of $4.43 down to $1.67, a 62% cut, with the largest reductions in cached-input pricing.

• Work360 score — 52.69 against 47.74 for Qwen3.8-Max.

None of those is a cross-lab comparison, and none can be checked against a competitor's published figures, because they are measured on benchmarks the vendor scores itself. The independent number arrived the same day from a different direction.

What the independent harness reads

Artificial Analysis v5.0.1 is a nine-evaluation composite — AA-Briefcase v1.1, AutomationBench-AA, Terminal-Bench 4.0, FrontierCode-AA 2.0, AA-Omniscience v1.1, GDP.pdf, HLE-Diamond, CritPt v2 Hard Subset and Terminal-Bench-Science 0.1 — run by the tracker, not by the labs. On it, Qwen4-Max's 43 sits at rank 38 of 81 models, a little above the field median of 41. That is a respectable debut for a first-generation architecture. It is not a leader, and the four models it was placed above are all ahead of it:

• Claude Opus 5.5 — 59 at Max, 57 at Xhigh, 52 at High, 48 at Medium, 35 at Low. Released 22 September 2026.

• GPT-6 Astra — 57 at Max, 55 at Xhigh, 55 at High, 52 at Medium, 43 at Low. Released 3 September 2026, knowledge cutoff April 2026.

• GPT-6.1 Sol — 55 at Max, 52 at Xhigh, 50 at High, 46 at Medium, 35 at Low. Released 29 September 2026.

• Claude Fable 5.2 — 65 at Max, 62 at Xhigh, 62 at High, 56 at Medium, 54 at Low. Released 9 November 2026.

• Qwen4-Max — 43, published as a single figure with no per-effort ladder. Released 16 November 2026.

That last asymmetry is the whole story. Qwen4-Max is a reasoning model, and the tracker grades its competitors at five separate reasoning settings while grading Qwen4-Max at one. Whatever setting produced the 43 is being compared to Opus 5.5's and Astra's and Sol's strongest, and the tracker does not tell you how much headroom sits below it. So "43 versus 59" is not a like-for-like comparison of the two models' ceilings — it is Qwen4-Max's single measured setting against Opus 5.5's best one.

The one reading under which the claim is true

Read the ladders downward and the claim stops being false and starts being misleading, which is a more interesting failure. Qwen4-Max's 43 is not beaten by every rung of every opponent. It clears or ties the bottom rung of three of the four:

• Against Claude Opus 5.5 — 43 beats the Low setting's 35 by eight points, and loses to Medium's 48 by five. The crossover sits between Low and Medium.

• Against GPT-6 Astra — 43 exactly ties Astra's Low setting of 43, and loses to Medium's 52 by nine.

• Against GPT-6.1 Sol — 43 beats Sol's Low setting of 35 by eight points, and loses to Medium's 46 by three. This is the closest call on the board.

• Against Claude Fable 5.2 — 43 loses to every rung, including the Low setting's 54, by eleven points. There is no setting of Fable 5.2 that Qwen4-Max reaches.

So a comparison that put Qwen4-Max against competitors running at Low effort would produce exactly the reported ordering for Opus 5.5 and Sol, exactly the reported tie-or-better against Astra, and exactly the reported loss to Fable 5.2. That is a coherent, self-consistent set of results, and it is the only set on this harness that produces the ordering in circulation. Whether anyone assembled it deliberately or arrived at it by comparing a default configuration against a lowest setting, the arithmetic lands there.

The practical consequence is the part that matters for anyone reading a launch thread rather than a scoreboard: at equal reasoning effort, Qwen4-Max is roughly one rung behind GPT-6.1 Sol and two rungs behind Claude Opus 5.5. That is a genuinely competitive debut. It is not a lead, and it is nowhere near the "outperforms" framing.

A generated two-column scoreboard titled 'Qwen4-Max vs Claude Opus 5.5 — the scoreboard'. The Qwen4-Max column reads 'Index at Max effort: 43', 'Lowest published effort: 43, single score', 'Blended price: $0.80 per million', 'Cost per index task: $3.27', 'Time per task: not published', 'Context window: 984k'. The Claude Opus 5.5 column reads 'Index at Max effort: 59', 'Lowest published effort: 35 at Low', 'Blended price: $2.94 per million', 'Cost per index task: $10.04', 'Time per task: 24.9 minutes', 'Context window: 1M'. A footer reads 'Index, per-task cost and time per task per Artificial Analysis v5.0.1, read 16 November 2026; prices per vendor cards.'

Cost per task separates two claims from one

Capability is only half of what the launch chatter asserted, and on money the picture is more favourable to Qwen4-Max — for two of the three models, and not the third.

• Sticker price — Qwen4-Max is $1.50 per million input and $4.50 per million output, with a 95% cache discount and a blended rate of $0.80 per million. That blended rate is the lowest of all five models here: GPT-6.1 Sol is $1.47, Claude Opus 5.5 $2.94, Claude Fable 5.2 $5.74 and GPT-6 Astra $7.70.

• Cost per completed task — Claude Fable 5.2 $26.54, Claude Opus 5.5 $10.04, GPT-6 Astra $6.24, Qwen4-Max $3.27, GPT-6.1 Sol $1.27. All at each model's Max setting.

• The inversion — Qwen4-Max has the cheapest blended rate on the board and the third-cheapest task. It beats Claude Opus 5.5 per task by a factor of three and GPT-6 Astra by roughly two, and loses to GPT-6.1 Sol by a factor of 2.6.

The mechanism is verbosity, and the tracker measures it directly: Qwen4-Max generated 127 million output tokens completing the index, against a field median of 78.6 million, and is classed as very verbose. A model that writes 60% more than the median spends its rate advantage doing so. A​libaba's own 24-to-35% token-reduction figures are real improvements against Qwen3.8-Max and say nothing about how verbose the model is in absolute terms, which is the number that reaches an invoice.

So the cost half of the claim splits cleanly. "Cheaper to run than Opus 5.5 and Astra" is true on a per-task basis, by a wide margin, and is the strongest thing in this article for Qwen4-Max. "Cheaper than GPT-6.1 Sol" is false per task by a factor of 2.6, even though Qwen4-Max's blended rate is 46% lower. Anyone who budgeted from the rate card and got the opposite answer on the bill has found the same gap.

The figure the tracker does not have

One column on the Qwen4-Max page is empty in a way that deserves flagging. Artificial Analysis reports time per task for every model it lists here — Claude Opus 5.5 at 24.9 minutes on Max, GPT-6 Astra at 20.9, GPT-6.1 Sol at 22.9, Claude Fable 5.2 at 41.8 — and reports N/A for Qwen4-Max, with the timing chart annotated "No publicly available API".

Read that annotation carefully before drawing a conclusion from it, because it is not a statement that the model cannot be called. A​libaba publishes per-token prices for Qwen4-Max and its launch post says API prices were lowered relative to Qwen3.8-Max, and the tracker itself lists A​libaba Cloud as the model's provider and quotes a $3.27 per-task cost. A model with a rate card, a provider and a measured per-task cost has an API. The more likely reading is that the timing measurement was not obtainable through whatever path the tracker used, and the page does not say which. The tracker's own FAQ, on the same page, says the model "is available via API through 1 provider", which does not square with the chart annotation either.

What survives the ambiguity is narrower and still useful: there is no independent latency figure for Qwen4-Max on the day it launched, while every model it is being compared to has one. If your workload is latency-sensitive, you are choosing on a number nobody has published yet, and the honest position is to measure it yourself before committing a production path to it.

A headless-browser screenshot of the Artificial Analysis model page for Qwen4 Max, captured 16 November 2026 in English, showing the Alibaba proprietary-model header with 'Released November 2026', the rank badges Intelligence #38/81, Performance Cost #44/80 and Verbosity #65/80, the price block reading In $1.50, Out $4.50 and Cache 95%, the $3.27 per intelligence index task figure, the 127M output-token count, the summary prose noting a score of 43 against a median of 41, and a technical specification block reading Reasoning Yes, Input modality Text+Image, Output modality Text and Context window 984k.

What holds up in the launch claims

Three of the factual assertions in circulation check out and are worth stating plainly, because a claim-check that only subtracts is not a claim-check:

• The context window — advertised at one million tokens, measured by the tracker at 984,000. That is a real million-token model, not a rounded-up 200K.

• Native vision — the tracker records text and image input with text output, matching the vendor's "native vision" description rather than an add-on encoder bolted to a text model.

• The price cut — $1.50 and $4.50 per million against Qwen3.8-Max's higher card, and the lowest blended rate among the five models compared here. The direction of the pricing story is not in dispute.

What does not hold up is the ranking, and the ranking is the part that was repeated most.

What to do with this on the day of launch

The useful move with a model like this is not to pick a side of the argument but to keep the option cheap. Qwen4-Max is a first-generation architecture at a genuinely low unit price with an independent score in the middle of the field and no latency figure — a profile that rewards a trial and punishes a migration.

That is what routing is for. Claude Opus 5.5, GPT-6 Astra, GPT-6.1 Sol and Claude Fable 5.2 are all routed on OrcaRouter at each vendor's list price with 0% markup, so a vendor rate change is live on the same day and the per-task arithmetic above stays current without a second contract or an SDK change. Qwen4-Max is not routed on OrcaRouter — it is reachable through A​libaba's own Model Studio API and several third-party platforms, and this article will not pretend otherwise. What routing buys you in that situation is the comparison: the four models it was measured against sit behind one key across 200-plus models, so benchmarking Qwen4-Max against them is a configuration change on one side of the fence rather than procurement on both.

And if Qwen4-Max does earn a place, automatic failover is what makes an unmeasured model safe to put in a live path — the request falls through to a model whose latency you do have, instead of failing when the new one is slow or unavailable in the way its missing timing figure hints it might be.

A headless-browser screenshot of the OrcaRouter model page for anthropic/claude-opus-5.5, captured 16 November 2026 in English, showing the FLAGSHIP and ZDR badges, the Claude Opus 5.5 heading with its identifier, the Anthropic attribution and 'Public benchmarks by Anthropic · 2026-09-22' line, Vision, Tools, JSON and Reasoning capability badges, a p50 time to first token of 7.98 s, a zero-data-retention availability note, the description placing it as Anthropic's flagship for reasoning, coding and long-horizon agentic work with a 1M-token context, the /v1/chat/completions and /v1/messages endpoints, and the price block reading $4.00 input and $20.00 output per million tokens.

The launch-day framing was that a cheap Chinese model had leapfrogged two American flagships. What the harness actually shows is a well-priced model one rung behind the cheapest of them and two rungs behind the best, with a real vision capability, a real million-token window, and no published speed. That is a better product than the claim made it sound and a worse ranking, and the difference between those two things is exactly the distance between a thread and a scoreboard.

Compared in this article2

Detected from this article · Benchmarks: Artificial Analysis · updated daily