Generated comparison card showing MAI Code 2 at $0.50 input and $2.50 output per million tokens against Claude Opus 5.5 at $4.00 and $20.00, with the 96 percent performance and 5 percent cost claim labelled as vendor-reported.
Guides & Insights

MAI Code 2 vs Claude Opus 5.5: What the 96%-for-5% Claim Leaves Out

Author

jinhao.song

Date Published

Latest models · 20View all models →
Benchmarks: Artificial Analysis · updated daily
Back to all posts

The comparison between MAI Code 2 and Claude Opus 5.5 has one number that everybody quotes and nobody can check. Microsoft says MAI Code 2 reaches 96% of Opus 5.5's performance across four coding benchmarks at 5% of the cost. Opus 5.5 has been generally available since 22 September 2026, carries a published rate card, and sits at 59 on the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index. MAI Code 2 shipped on 17 November 2026 with a rate card of its own and no independent score at all — it is callable inside GitHub Copilot and nowhere else, and Artificial Analysis had no row for it when this was written. So the honest comparison is not two columns of numbers. It is one model you can measure and one model you can only take Microsoft's word for, plus a price difference large enough that the word is worth taking seriously until someone tests it.

The two rate cards, before any percentages

Microsoft bills MAI Code 2 per token through GitHub Copilot under usage-based billing, at promotional rates that expire on a published date. Anthropic bills Opus 5.5 per token at list, with no expiry.

Side-by-side rate card comparing MAI Code 2 at $0.50 input, $2.50 output and $0.025 cached input per million tokens with Claude Opus 5.5 at $4.00, $20.00 and $0.20, showing an 8x gap that narrows to 4x after 17 May 2027.

• Input — MAI Code 2 at $0.50 per million tokens vs Claude Opus 5.5 at $4.00; Opus costs 8× more per input token

• Output — $2.50 vs $20.00 per million; the same 8× gap

• Cached input — $0.025 vs $0.20 per million; again 8×

• After 17 May 2027 — MAI Code 2 reprices to $1.00 / $0.05 / $5.00, which narrows the gap to 4× input and 4× output

• Context — Opus 5.5 published a round 1,000,000; MAI Code 2 published 1,050,000, which is 5% more window and no more useful without retrieval that holds up at the far end

• Maximum output — 128,000 tokens on both

• Input modality — Opus 5.5 accepts files alongside text and images; the MAI Code 2 model card lists text and images only

• Weight availability — you cannot download either one, for different reasons: Opus 5.5 is proprietary, and MAI Code 2 is sold only as a hosted service

That table is where the two models are genuinely comparable, and it produces a price ratio of 12.5%, not 5%. The 5% figure is a cost-per-task number, which is a different measurement: it divides total spend by tasks completed, so it absorbs how many tokens each model burns at maximum reasoning effort. A model that reasons more efficiently, or simply stops earlier, can land at 5% while charging 12.5% per token. The model card confirms all comparisons were run at max effort, which is exactly the setting where token counts diverge most.

What the 96% is built from, and who ran it

Four benchmarks sit under the 96%: DeepSWE 1.1, Terminal Bench 2.1, SWE Atlas and FrontierCode v1.1. Three of them came out of MSBench, Microsoft's internal evaluation platform, run through the GitHub Copilot CLI at version 1.0.102 with subagents disabled. The fourth, FrontierCode, is Artificial Analysis data. Microsoft's own model card gives the raw pass rates at max reasoning effort: 73.2% on DeepSWE 1.1, 84.6% on TerminalBench 2.1 and 43.1% on SWE Atlas.

Read those three numbers without the percentage framing and a different picture appears. SWE Atlas is the weakest of the three at 43.1%, and it is also the benchmark in the set that is not about fixing a bug: it grades codebase question answering, test writing and refactoring against rubric as well as programmatic checks. A model tuned for "changes code maintainers would merge" can do well on issue-resolution tests and still be mediocre at explaining a codebase. Microsoft does not publish the per-benchmark split against Opus 5.5, only the average, so there is no way to see which of the four is carrying the 96% and which is dragging it.

Opus 5.5's own vendor numbers point in a similar direction from the other side. Anthropic's launch material reported Terminal-Bench 4.0 at 66.4% and GDPval-AA v2.1 at 1,846 Elo. Those are also vendor-reported, also unreproduced by Microsoft's harness, and on a different benchmark version entirely — Terminal-Bench 4.0 versus Microsoft's 2.1. Two vendors quoting different versions of the same family of test is not a comparison. It is two advertisements facing each other.

What an independent evaluator actually says about Opus 5.5

Opus 5.5 is one of the few models in this bracket with a full third-party record. Artificial Analysis puts it at 59 on the Intelligence Index v5.0.1, a nine-evaluation composite that runs from Terminal-Bench 4.0 through FrontierCode-AA 2.0 to Terminal-Bench-Science 0.1. The supporting figures are the ones to plan around: $10.04 per index task, 24.5 minutes per task, 118 tokens per second of output and 358 seconds to first answer token.

Screenshot of the Artificial Analysis page for Claude Opus 5.5 showing an Intelligence Index of 59, $4.00 input and $20.00 output per million tokens, $10.04 per index task, 24.5 minutes per task, 118 output tokens per second and a 1M-token context window.

Two of those numbers matter more than the score. The 358-second time to first answer token is what a user staring at a spinner experiences, and the 24.5 minutes per task is the wall clock a long agent run actually costs. Opus 5.5 is not a fast model; it is a thorough one. A cheaper competitor does not have to match 96% of its accuracy to win a workload — it only has to be good enough at the specific task, and considerably faster or cheaper at the margin. That is the whole argument for a price-performance model, and Microsoft is making it without the independent evidence that would settle it.

Where MAI Code 2 cannot go yet

This is the part the percentage hides. MAI Code 2 ships inside GitHub Copilot, on every paid tier from Pro to Enterprise, in every editor GitHub extends into. That is a broad set of surfaces and a single vendor's plumbing. There is no Foundry deployment for the large model at launch; only MAI Code 2 Flash has a Foundry preview, through an OpenAI-compatible Responses API. Microsoft says further availability is coming, names no date, and distributes no weights.

Opus 5.5, by contrast, is on Anthropic's own API and three major clouds, with a model ID, a published retirement floor and a documented snapshot policy. If your work happens inside Copilot, the comparison is live today. If it happens in your own agent framework, your CI pipeline or a multi-vendor stack, one side of this comparison is a press release.

The workload split that actually decides it

• Routine enterprise repair — mergeable fixes, multi-file edits, deep debugging inside a known repository — is the task Microsoft built and priced for. At 12.5% of Opus's per-token rate today, even a model that needs a second attempt to reach the same pass rate can be cheaper per finished task.

• Long-horizon agentic work is where Microsoft says the model is not tuned, in the announcement and again in the model card. Opus 5.5's entire positioning is that workload, and its 1,846 Elo on GDPval-AA is the number Anthropic chose to lead with.

• Non-English codebases — not an inference but a line in the model card: English code production only at release, with less common languages explicitly under-evaluated. Opus 5.5 ships no equivalent caveat.

• Anything that takes a consequential action without a human in the loop is out of scope on both sides, but Microsoft says so explicitly for MAI Code 2 and asks for supervised agentic workflows.

• Context above one million tokens is a tie in practice. Both claim roughly a million; neither number should be trusted as a working budget without testing retrieval at the far end.

Running both sides of the ledger

Claude Opus 5.5 is on OrcaRouter's catalogue at $4.00 input and $20.00 output per million tokens, provider list price passed through with 0% markup, so a vendor price change reaches your bill the day it happens rather than the day a reseller updates a sheet. That matters more than usual in a comparison like this one, because MAI Code 2's own price doubles on 17 May 2027 — the ratio you are evaluating today is not the ratio you will be paying in June.

Screenshot of OrcaRouter's Claude Opus 5.5 model page listing the $4.00 input and $20.00 output per million token rates, a 1M-token context, 128K maximum output and zero data retention availability.

MAI Code 2 is not on our catalogue, and the only published route to it is GitHub Copilot. If Microsoft opens a Foundry endpoint for the large model, the sensible first move is not a migration but a shadow run: keep Opus 5.5 on the path that matters, route the cheap model at the tasks you already know the answer to, and compare finished-task cost rather than token price. That is the shape of decision automatic failover exists for — a new, unproven model on a fraction of the traffic, with a proven one behind it if the cheap side stalls.

The verdict that survives the evidence: Opus 5.5 is the model to keep for the work nobody wants to redo, and MAI Code 2 is the model to test on the work that runs every day. Microsoft's 96% may well hold in Copilot's own harness. It has not been tested anywhere that could contradict it, and until it is, the 5% is a claim and the 12.5% is a rate card.