Two cards split by a divider: GPT-6.2 Astra reading 74 s to first token, 728 s at 10k tokens and $8 / $40 per million, and Claude Opus 5.5 reading 625 s to first token, 373 s at 10k tokens and $4 / $20 per million, under the subtitle 'Time to first token, max effort, one-thousand-token prompt'. The OrcaRouter logo sits in the bottom-right corner.
Guides & Insights

GPT-6.2 Astra vs Claude Opus 5.5: Four Minutes vs Ten Before the First Token

Author

jinhao.song

Date Published

Latest models · 20View all models →
Benchmarks: Artificial Analysis · updated daily
Back to all posts

Put the same short prompt to both models and time the silence. On Artificial Analysis's measurements at maximum effort, Claude Opus 5.5 takes 625 seconds — a little over ten minutes — before its first token appears on a one-thousand-token prompt. GPT-6.2 Astra answers the same shape of request in 74 seconds. Four minutes against ten, before either model has written a word, and the gap widens to nearly eight minutes at a ten-thousand-token prompt: 728 seconds against 373.

That is the number I would start with, because the headline comparison points somewhere else entirely. GPT-6.2 Astra, which OpenAI released on 17 November 2026 at $8 and $40 per million tokens, costs twice as much as Claude Opus 5.5 on both sides of the meter — Anthropic's model has held $4 and $20 since 22 September 2026. Sticker price says Opus 5.5 is the economical choice. The measured bill says the opposite by a factor of 2.5, and the latency numbers say something else again. All three are true at once, and the reason is that the two models spend very differently to reach a similar score.

Two points of index, four times the tokens

On Intelligence Index v5.0.1, read on 19 November 2026 and both models run at maximum effort, the scores are 62.1 for GPT-6.2 Astra and 59.1 for Claude Opus 5.5. Three points on a nine-evaluation suite is a real lead but not a rout, and it is smaller than the spread between different effort settings on either model.

What separates them is the cost of arriving there. Artificial Analysis weights a finished Index task at $4.00 on GPT-6.2 Astra and $10.04 on Claude Opus 5.5 — 2.5 times as much, from a rate card that is half the price. The mechanism is tokens per task: across the same suite, GPT-6.2 Astra produced about 41,000 output tokens per task against Opus 5.5's 173,000. Four times the thinking for three points less, and the token count is a property of how the model is built rather than something a provider or a GPU allocation can fix.

That inversion is worth internalising before reading any comparison of these two, because it makes every per-token argument misleading. A team budgeting from the rate card would expect Astra to cost twice as much and would actually pay 40 cents on the dollar.

The scoreboard, with the harness attached

All figures below are Artificial Analysis's independent measurements on the same suite at maximum effort, which matters because vendor tables are run at settings and harnesses the vendor chooses. One exception is flagged in the row itself.

• Intelligence Index — 62.1 for GPT-6.2 Astra vs 59.1 for Claude Opus 5.5, on v5.0.1

• Cost per Index task — $4.00 vs $10.04

• Time per Index task — 10.7 minutes vs 24.5 minutes

• Terminal-Bench 4.0 — 64.1% vs 59.6%

• Terminal-Bench-Science 0.1 — 78.1% vs 59.0%, the widest gap in this piece

• FrontierCode 2.0 — 45.4% vs 46.4%, the one coding suite where Opus 5.5 is ahead

• HLE-Diamond — 72.2% vs 67.9%

• AnalystAgent — 62.5% vs 56.3%

• HARVEY LAB-AA — 15.0% vs 4.2%, a 3.6× ratio on legal deliverables

• Omniscience accuracy — 68.6% vs 65.5%, with hallucination rates of 59.1% vs 50.3%

• HealthBench — 53.5% vs 57.0%, a genuine Opus 5.5 win

• AA-3D Elo — 1,318 vs 1,202, though the 1,318 is OpenAI's own reported figure for Astra on Artificial Analysis's 3D arena

• Context and output — 1,000,000 tokens and 128,000 output on both, per Artificial Analysis's catalogue; OpenAI's own model page lists 1,050,000 total with a 922,000-token input ceiling

A two-column scoreboard for GPT-6.2 Astra against Claude Opus 5.5 across six shared dimensions: Intelligence Index 62.1 vs 59.1, cost per task $4.00 vs $10.04, time per task 10.7 min vs 24.5 min, output tokens per task about 41,000 vs about 173,000, time to first token 74 s vs 625 s, and hallucination rate 59.1% vs 50.3%. The OrcaRouter logo sits in the bottom-right corner.

Where Claude Opus 5.5 still wins, and why it matters

The rows where Anthropic's model leads are not random, and reading them together tells you what it is good at. FrontierCode 2.0 measures whether a change to a real codebase would pass maintainer review, and Opus 5.5 edges it by a point — inside noise, but consistently in the direction of accepting a patch a human would. HealthBench is clinical conversation, where it leads by 3.5 points. And its hallucination rate is nearly nine points lower: 50.3% against 59.1%, meaning on questions it cannot answer correctly, Opus 5.5 is more likely to say so.

That last row deserves its own sentence, because it is the kind of number that never makes a launch post. GPT-6.2 Astra is more accurate on the omniscience suite and considerably less disciplined about admitting ignorance. For a workflow where a wrong answer is expensive to catch — legal research, medical summarisation, financial fact-checking — a nine-point gap in confession rate can outweigh a three-point gap in score, and it is the single strongest argument for keeping Claude Opus 5.5 in the loop even on a stack that has otherwise standardised on Astra.

Anthropic's own launch material prints Terminal-Bench 4.0 at 66.4% for Opus 5.5, against the 59.6% above. That is not a contradiction: the vendor figure is taken at xhigh effort rather than the model's default of medium, on Anthropic's own harness. Three numbers for one benchmark across three configurations is exactly why every row in this piece names its source.

The effort dial changes both answers

Neither model's published score is its out-of-the-box score, and the defaults are not symmetric. Claude Opus 5.5 defaults to medium effort on the Claude API; every figure above is at max. A team that deploys Opus 5.5 without setting effort gets less of the latency back and less of the score, and there is no published table for where that lands — the effort curve exists, but the independent numbers sit at its top.

GPT-6.2 Astra's ladder starts at low and rejects none outright, so the cheapest setting is still a reasoning setting. That is a small architectural difference with a practical consequence: on Astra you cannot accidentally turn reasoning off and get a fast, cheap, worse model; on Opus 5.5 the analogous lever is the effort parameter itself, and the gap between medium and max is where most of the ten-minute first token lives.

If your decision hinges on the three-point index gap, check that you will actually run the setting that produces it. Both models are being compared at their most expensive configuration, and only one of them ships that way by default.

Above 272,000 tokens, the tables cross

Per-token pricing is where this comparison has a genuine structural asymmetry, and it is not the one the headline rates suggest. Claude Opus 5.5 bills its full one-million-token window at a flat $4 in and $20 out, with cache reads at $0.20 — five per cent of base input — and cache writes at $5 for five minutes or $8 for an hour.

GPT-6.2 Astra charges $8 and $40 short-context, then doubles input and cache and multiplies output by 1.5 for any request above 272,000 input tokens, applying the higher rate to the whole request rather than the excess. Cross that line with a 300,000-token prompt and the effective rate is $16 in, $60 out and $0.80 cached. Against Opus 5.5's flat $4 and $20, the four-fold output gap that makes Astra cheap has to survive a price table that just tripled.

• Cache reads — Opus 5.5 at $0.20 per million vs Astra at $0.40, doubling to $0.80 above 272K

• Cache writes — Opus 5.5 at $5 for five minutes and $8 for an hour, against Astra's $10 for 30 minutes and $20 for 12 hours

• Long-context behaviour — Opus 5.5 flat across 1M vs Astra at 2× input and 1.5× output for the entire request above 272K

• Batch — both discount 50%, and both windows remain open

This is why the cheap-model verdict is not universal. A coding agent working through a large monorepo, a document pipeline ingesting 400-page contracts, anything that routinely carries a few hundred thousand tokens of context: on those workloads Claude Opus 5.5 is not the expensive option. It is the only one of the two whose price does not move when the prompt grows, and the per-task advantage Astra earns from token efficiency narrows as the input share of the bill rises.

A long-context pricing chart split by a dashed marker at 272K input tokens: below the marker Claude Opus 5.5 at $4 in and $20 out against GPT-6.2 Astra at $8 in and $40 out, and above it Opus 5.5 still flat at $4 / $20 while Astra steps up to $16 / $60, with callout cards reading 'Cache read: $0.20 vs $0.40, then $0.80', 'Cache write: $5 an hour vs $20 for 12 hours' and 'Astra applies the higher rate to the whole request'. The OrcaRouter logo sits in the bottom-right corner.

What the 40% window does to the arithmetic

Since 17 November, GPT-6.2 Astra has a second price that Opus 5.5 has no counterpart for. In the Responses API's background mode, an eight-hour completion window bills model token rates 40% below Standard — $4.80 input, $24 output, $0.24 cached — and a two-hour window bills 30% below. Applied to the $4.00 measured task cost, that is roughly $2.40 a task in the deep window against Opus 5.5's $10.04.

It is not free money, and the constraints are the interesting part. The window requires Standard processing, forbids streaming, shares a rate-limit budget with Batch jobs, and splits the prompt cache — entries written by a windowed request cannot be read by a Standard one. For a nightly pipeline that is a rounding error. For an interactive coding session it is unusable, and the ten-minute first token above is exactly the number that decides which side of that line your workload sits on.

The comparison this creates is unusually clean. If your work can wait until morning, GPT-6.2 Astra is 4.2 times cheaper per finished task than Claude Opus 5.5 and roughly twice as fast. If it cannot wait, the price advantage is 2.5 times and the latency advantage is still there but the ten minutes belong to Opus 5.5's first token rather than to a queue you chose.

The one place the two vendors agree

Both models cleared the same safety bar in the same direction. OpenAI's 6.2 system card places GPT-6.2 Astra at the Critical threshold for cybersecurity and High for biological and chemical capabilities under its Preparedness Framework, and the launch shipped with tighter refusals for high-risk cyber assistance as a result — which its own documentation concedes restricts some legitimate vulnerability research. Claude Opus 5.5 sits under Anthropic's equivalent regime. If your work is defensive security tooling, both models will push back on some of it, and neither vendor is currently offering the discounted background windows as a substitute for the dedicated cyber programme access they describe separately.

That is a real cost on both sides and it does not show up in any of the numbers above. Plan for it: a workflow that assumes unrestricted exploitation assistance will fail on either model, and the failure will look like a refusal rather than a benchmark result.

Choosing, and then not choosing

If you have to pick one and your work is scientific computing, long-horizon professional deliverables, or anything where the answer arrives on a schedule you control, GPT-6.2 Astra wins on every axis that has a number attached — score, cost per task, wall clock, and the option of another 40% for patience. If your work is clinical, or fact-critical enough that a model's willingness to admit ignorance is worth more than its ceiling, Claude Opus 5.5 is the better instrument and the 2.5× premium is the price of that discipline. If you routinely carry more than a quarter-million tokens of context, the pricing table alone decides it and Opus 5.5 is cheaper by a wide margin.

Most production systems do not have to take the bet. Both models live behind a single key on OrcaRouter — anthropic/claude-opus-5.5 for the review and verification pass, the OpenAI routes alongside it — at provider list price with 0% markup, so a vendor cut on either side reaches the same key the day it lands. A configuration that sends planning and final review to Opus 5.5 and the bulk of execution and analysis to GPT-6.2 Astra prices out well below either pure choice, and automatic failover on the Opus route is what keeps a ten-minute time-to-first-token from becoming a ten-minute outage when the provider has a bad hour. That is the shape most teams converge on after the first bill, and it is available before the first bill if you route from the start.

What would change this verdict: an independent GPT-6.2 Astra score at medium effort, which would tell you whether the latency advantage survives when it is asked to think as long as Opus 5.5 does, and a second measurement cycle on the hallucination row, which is the only figure here that argues against the cheaper model on grounds money cannot fix.

The Artificial Analysis model page for GPT-6.2 Astra, an independent third-party measurement site, showing the model's Intelligence Index score and its measured latency and per-task cost panels.