A self-built hero title card for 'Claude Fable 5.1 vs Grok 4.6' with the subtitle 'Nine index points, an eightfold output price'. Two panels: 'Claude Fable 5.1' (Anthropic, closed API, 0.00 / 0.00 per 1M tokens, AA Intelligence Index 53, #1 of 201) and 'Grok 4.6' (SpaceXAI, closed API, .00 / .00 per 1M tokens, AA Intelligence Index 44, #20 of 201). A footer reads 'Claude Fable 5.1 launched Sep 1, 2026 \u00b7 Grok 4.6 launched Aug 12, 2026 \u00b7 Independent figures, current Artificial Analysis index, captured Sep 10, 2026'; the OrcaRouter logo sits bottom-right.
Guides & Insights

Claude Fable 5.1 vs Grok 4.6: Nine Index Points and an Eightfold Output Price — What the Gap Actually Buys

Author

Elias Hawthorne

Date Published

Latest models · 20View all models →
Benchmarks: Artificial Analysis · updated daily
Back to all posts

Claude Fable 5.1 and Grok 4.6 are the two closed frontier models that bracket the current generation's price range. Anthropic's new flagship, released September 1, 2026, charges $10.00 per million input tokens and $50.00 per million output tokens, and on the current version of Artificial Analysis's Intelligence Index it sits at 53 — first of the 201 models that index tracks. SpaceXAI's Grok 4.6, out since August 12, charges $2.00 and $6.00 for those same units and measures 44, twentieth of 201. Nine index points separate them. Eight times the output price separates them. Which of those two numbers a given workload should care about is the whole question, and they point in different directions depending on what you are asking the model to do.

Sourcing, declared up front: Artificial Analysis re-scored its Intelligence Index in September, so the figures here are drawn from the current version, captured on September 10, 2026, rather than from the older scale still quoted in a lot of August coverage. Index scores from different versions are not comparable, which is why the numbers below may look lower than what you read about either model at launch. Everything labeled vendor-reported comes from the launching lab's own evaluation sheet and has not been reproduced by a neutral party. That caveat weighs unevenly here — Grok 4.6 has had a month of outside scrutiny, while Claude Fable 5.1 is nine days old and most of what is publicly known about its headline numbers is still Anthropic's word.

Two labs, two different things on sale

Anthropic's September release is a capability play with a safety story bolted to it. Claude Fable 5.1 is the generally available twin of Claude Mythos 5.1, the safety-restricted sibling that only reaches vetted cybersecurity and life-science organisations — same base model, different guardrails. What Anthropic is selling is the top of the independent index, a 1M-token context window, up to 128K output tokens in a single response, and an agent ecosystem built around Claude Code and the Claude apps. The pitch is straightforward: this is the model you call when the work is hard enough that a wrong answer costs more than the tokens did.

SpaceXAI is selling something narrower and, over time, more aggressive — the cheapest model that is still frontier-class, priced low enough to make building agents on anything else look extravagant. Grok 4.6 is not a scale-up: it is the same foundation as Grok 4.5 with a longer supplemental training run and heavier reinforcement learning, which the vendor says buys "intelligence comparable to GPT-5.6 Sol and Claude Fable 5." At $2/$6, and still inside the top twenty of the index, that is the entire argument. It is also a strategy, not just a price. SpaceXAI owns Cursor, shipped its Grok Bot browser agent the day before the model, and runs its own consumer chat apps; a frontier model at commodity prices is fuel for all of them. Elon Musk's public arithmetic — AI revenue overtaking every other company segment, 10 GW of compute — points the same way. This model is not priced to maximise API margin.

The spec sheet, dimension by dimension

• Price per 1M tokens — Claude Fable 5.1 $10.00 in / $50.00 out vs Grok 4.6 $2.00 in / $6.00 out.

• Cached input — Claude Fable 5.1 $0.25 per 1M vs Grok 4.6 $0.50, and Artificial Analysis lists an effective cache discount of 98% against 75%.

• Long-context pricing — Claude Fable 5.1 prices its window flat all the way to 1M tokens; Grok 4.6 reprices the entire request to $4.00 / $12.00 / $1.00 the moment it crosses 200K input tokens, so its discount thins exactly where long agent runs live.

• Context and output — Claude Fable 5.1 carries a 1M-token context window and up to 128K output tokens vs Grok 4.6's 500K context window, a reasoning-effort dial running from low to xhigh, and a faster variant at double the rate.

• Independent score, speed and cost — Artificial Analysis has Claude Fable 5.1 at 53 on its current Intelligence Index (#1 of 201), 67.2 output tokens per second, and $7.63 per index task; Grok 4.6 sits at 44 (#20 of 201), 52.8 tokens per second, and $1.86 per task. Both are rated "very verbose" or "somewhat verbose" by that measurement — 190M output tokens for the Claude model against 94M for Grok.

• Vendor benchmark claims — Anthropic reports 52.6% on Terminal-Bench-Science 0.1 (more than double the 24.7% of Claude Fable 5), 55.8% on Terminal-Bench 4.0 and 1,853 on GDPval-AA v2 for Claude Fable 5.1. SpaceXAI reports 65.9% on DeepSWE v1.1 and 69.9% on CursorBench v3.2 for Grok 4.6, alongside a self-reported 26% on Terminal-Bench v3.0 — the one line in the vendor's own table that is notably soft.

• Where each one runs — Anthropic's API, the Claude apps, Claude Code, Amazon Bedrock, Google Cloud and Microsoft Foundry vs the SpaceXAI API, Cursor, Grok Build, the Grok Bot agent, the Grok consumer apps and Amazon Bedrock GovCloud.

• Released — Claude Fable 5.1 on September 1, 2026; Grok 4.6 on August 12, 2026.

A self-built two-column scoreboard titled 'Claude Fable 5.1 vs Grok 4.6 \u2014 the scoreboard'. Left column 'Claude Fable 5.1 (Anthropic)': 'AA Intelligence Index 53 (#1 of 201)', 'Price in / out 0.00 / 0.00 per 1M tokens', 'Cost per index task .63', 'Context / max output 1M / 128K', 'AA output speed 67.2 tok/s', 'Released Sep 1, 2026'. Right column 'Grok 4.6 (SpaceXAI)': 'AA Intelligence Index 44 (#20 of 201)', 'Price in / out .00 / .00 per 1M tokens', 'Cost per index task .86', 'Context / max output 500K, repriced above 200K', 'AA output speed 52.8 tok/s', 'Released Aug 12, 2026'. Footer: 'AA figures per Artificial Analysis, current index version, captured Sep 10 2026.'

What nine index points actually represent

On the current independent index the September order is unambiguous: Claude Fable 5.1 at 53 and first of 201, Grok 4.6 at 44 and twentieth. The re-scored index needs one clarification, because it is the kind of thing that makes launch-week numbers look wrong in retrospect: Artificial Analysis restated its Intelligence Index in September, and both models' published scores moved down when it did. A nine-point spread is real, but the index is a weighted composite — heavily tilted toward agentic work, with coding, scientific reasoning and general capability behind it — so it compresses a mixed per-dimension picture into a single line.

The per-dimension evidence is noisier and more useful. Anthropic's own Terminal-Bench-Science 0.1 figure — 52.6%, more than double the previous generation's 24.7% — targets exactly the long-horizon scientific and research workflows that agentic buyers care about, and no current model approaches it on that specific benchmark. SpaceXAI's vendor table is strongest on software engineering (65.9% DeepSWE v1.1, 69.9% CursorBench v3.2) and weakest on terminal-heavy agent loops, where Grok 4.6's own 26% on Terminal-Bench v3.0 sits below GPT-5.6 Sol Max's 34.6% and Claude Fable 5 Max's 34.1%. Both tables are vendor-reported and unreproduced; they describe where each lab believes it is strong, not who wins.

Screenshot of the Artificial Analysis model page for Claude Fable 5.1 (Adaptive Reasoning, Max Effort, Default Fallback), captured September 10, 2026, showing Intelligence Index 53 ranked #1 of 201, output speed 67.2 tokens per second, a .63 cost per Intelligence Index task, a 98% cache discount against 0.00 input and 0.00 output pricing, 190M output tokens of verbosity, and a 1M-token context window.

The fine print on cheap tokens

Grok 4.6's price advantage is real, and at short and medium context it is enormous: an output-heavy workload pays roughly 83% less per generated token than it does on Claude Fable 5.1. But the rate card has three edges that a frontier comparison usually skips.

The first is the 200K threshold. Crossing 200,000 input tokens reprices the whole request to $4/$12, not just the tokens above the line. For a long agent run that accumulates context — the exact workload both models are sold for — the effective rate doubles without warning and stops being a fifth of Claude's price. The second is the faster variant, which costs double the base rate and is the only advertised way to fix the model's below-average output speed. The third is server-side tool calls, billed separately per thousand invocations.

Claude Fable 5.1's September pricing change cuts the other way. The nominal $10/$50 didn't move, but the cache-read price fell 75% to $0.25 per million tokens, which is where long agentic sessions actually spend their money: re-reading tool output, file contents and prior turns over and over. Artificial Analysis shows the resulting effective cache discount at 98%, against 75% for Grok. Paying a quarter per million re-read tokens changes the arithmetic of a multi-hour agent in a way the headline rate never shows.

The honest counterweight is verbosity, and it is the reason the real cost gap is not eightfold. Because the Claude model emits about twice as many tokens to finish the same index task — 190M against Grok's 94M — Artificial Analysis's cost-per-task measure lands at $7.63 for Claude Fable 5.1 against $1.86 for Grok 4.6. That is a factor of roughly four, not eight, and it is the number to plan a budget against.

The difference that never makes the table

Latency is where the two models diverge for interactive products, and the result is the opposite of what the price tag implies. Artificial Analysis measures Claude Fable 5.1 at 67.2 output tokens per second — above the average of its class — against 52.8 for Grok 4.6, which that measurement rates below average; the index summary for Grok has pointedly described it as slower than its peers, which is precisely why SpaceXAI sells a faster variant at double the rate. Anthropic's model is also, by that same independent note, the more verbose of the two. So the cheap model is the slower one, and the expensive model writes more than it needs to: two costs that pull in opposite directions and neither of which appears on the rate card.

Calling both without committing to either today

The practical consequence of a nine-point gap, a fourfold cost-per-task difference and a price card full of tiers is that most teams should be running both, and the interesting question is where the switch sits. That is cheaper to do than it sounds: Claude Fable 5.1 and Grok 4.6 are both on OrcaRouter at their providers' list prices with zero markup — the $2/$6 and $10/$50 above are the numbers that appear on the invoice, and any vendor price change moves through the same day rather than being absorbed into a reseller margin. One endpoint covers both, so the escalation pattern is a routing rule instead of a second contract: send high-volume, well-scoped work to Grok 4.6, escalate to Claude Fable 5.1 when the task needs the reasoning ceiling, and let automatic failover cover the case where the cheaper model's throughput is too slow for a deadline. The routing DSL expresses that chain in one place, and model fusion lets a panel of models answer together when a task is important enough to want more than one opinion. The price gap then stops being a decision you make once and becomes a line you tune as your workload mix moves.

Screenshot of the OrcaRouter model page for Grok 4.6 (model id grok/grok-4.6) showing .00 input and .00 output per 1M tokens, the SpaceXAI provider listed as of 2026-08-12, a 500K-token context window with text, image and file input, Vision, Tools, JSON and Reasoning capability badges, endpoints /v1/chat/completions and /v1/responses, and a p50 time-to-first-token of 10.00 seconds.

Who should pick which

Pick Claude Fable 5.1 when the cost of a wrong or abandoned answer dominates the cost of tokens: long-horizon agentic research, hard reasoning, regulated work where Anthropic's safety envelope and its phased zero-data-retention controls matter, and anything that lives inside Claude Code. Pick Grok 4.6 when the work is high-volume, well-scoped and throughput-tolerant — batch coding, extraction, generation, agent loops whose turns are short enough to stay under the 200K reprice line — and when you are building agents where the model is a component and cost per task is the whole business case.

Two open loops are worth watching before either choice hardens. SpaceXAI has already re-teased Grok 4.7 for the near term, and if it inherits the same price tier at higher capability, today's bargain becomes mid-tier within weeks. Anthropic, meanwhile, has shown a roughly monthly cadence and a willingness to cut cache pricing without touching headline rates, which suggests the next move in this matchup may be on the cost side of the ledger rather than the index. Neither loop changes what the models do today, but both are reasons to keep the model ID a configuration value. On one endpoint with pass-through pricing and failover, that is the default rather than a project.

Compared in this article2

Detected from this article · Benchmarks: Artificial Analysis · updated daily